I am a first-time Cannes Lions Judge. I’m thrilled to be one of the chosen carrying the flag here for Canada. As Terry Savage, CEO of Cannes Lions put it,”Your role here is very important. Marketers are hanging by their fingernails to hear your results. Careers swing on this.”
I am a member of the Promotions and Activations Jury. When I met Sir John Hegarty last month at Future Flash, he confided in me his envy. “It’s one of the most innovative categories these days.” He is judging television and had spent the last several weeks pre-judging. His eyeballs looked screen-shaped.
In my category there are over 3,000 entries. The first few days are spent without debate, each judge privately assigning a mark from 1 to 9 on their personal tablet. To have a chance at even making the shortlist you must score 4 or higher. Rob Schwartz, the Creative President of TBWA/Worldwide, heads up my jury. His directions were clear: recognize only the work you wished you’d done. The work that makes you feel something. We were also warned to flag “scam work” early in the judging. It’s not a witch-hunt by any means, but no one wants to discover a plagiarized idea twoThe Leisurely Pace of Judging Yesterday we judged for 17 hours. I got in at 2:45 am. I will file later today. It’s crazy here. hours before the Grand Prix. We were also cautioned against “patriotic voting” – whether it be by nation or network, the system flags it. If we are judging much higher or much lower than fellow judges, we will also be flagged. And so it begins.
* * *
Judging the Judges
Many wonder how one gets chosen to be a Cannes judge. You have to run the gauntlet and it’s not for the faint of heart. Looking around at the various juries here, I see that the median age is probably mid- to late 40s. Here’s why. The process goes like this: you have to be nominated by a group of Canadians who are affiliated with the Cannes Lions. Then you make your submission. Your submission must include your biography, the work you are most proud of, your picture, and a list of shows you have previously judged … plus a list of the awards you’ve personally won. And by the way, if you haven’t won at Cannes before, you cannot judge it. So before the judges get to judge, they are judged. Ah, the circle is complete.
* * *
The Leisurely Pace of Judging
Yesterday we judged for 17 hours. I got in at 2:45 am. I will file later today. It’s crazy here.
* * *
Freed from the Velvet Prison
After 17 hours of deliberation, eight bottles of Evian and and fuelled by late night sushi we arrived at the Grand Prix winner, and were freed from our meeting room. it was unanimous: "Immortal Fans" by Sport Club Recife by Ogilvy in Sao Paulo. This extraordinary campaign compelled fans to sign up for organ donation (Brazil has one of the lowest rates in the world) so they could continue to be fans, even in their afterlife. It pulled at the heart strings– quite literally–and was wildly successful. Go look at it. Fabulous. Organ donation is an issue in Canada too. Hey, can someone talk to the Leafs, please?
Back to the Croissette. This time in search of Lee Clow or Lou Reed. Whoever comes first.